Skip to content
NOWCAST KCCI News at 6am Weekday Morning
Live Now
Advertisement

'Fetal heartbeat' bill: How each Iowa lawmaker voted in special session

'Fetal heartbeat' bill: How each Iowa lawmaker voted in special session
LINE OF STORMS AS IT MOVES THROUGH. JASON, THANK YOU. WE WANT TO GET BACK TO THE BREAKING NEWS FROM THE IOWA STATE HOUSE. LAWMAKERS HAVE APPROVED NEW ABORTION RESTRICTIONS FOR OUR STATE. THIS ALL HAPPENED OVERNIGHT. THE FINAL VOTE CAME JUST BEFORE 11:00 DEADLINE LAST NIGHT. CASEY CERES ALYSSA GOMEZ IS THERE OUTSIDE THE STATE HOUSE BUILDING THIS MORNING. AND ALYSSA, HOW DOES HOW DID THIS BILL GET TO THE GOVERNOR’S DESK THIS MORNING? WELL, IT WAS AN EXTREMELY LONG NIGHT OF DEBATE FROM BOTH SIDES LAST NIGHT, BUT IT ALL CAME DOWN TO A 32 TO 17 VOTE THAT PASSED IN THE IOWA SENATE LAST NIGHT IN JUST TWO HOURS BEFORE THAT, THE MEASURE HAD PASSED IN THE HOUSE AROUND 9 P.M. IF SIGNED BY THE GOVERNOR, THE BILL WOULD BAN MOST ABORTIONS. ONCE THERE IS A QUOTE, DETECTABLE FETAL HEARTBEAT. DOCTORS SAY CARDIAC ACTIVITY GENERALLY HAPPENS AROUND SIX WEEKS OF PREGNANCY. THE BILL DOES ALLOW FOR SOME EXCEPTIONS IN CASES OF RAPE, INCEST OR MEDICAL EMERGENCIES. IT EMOTIONAL TESTIMONIES WERE HEARD FROM LAWMAKERS THROUGHOUT THE DAY. I BELIEVE TO MY CORE THAT INTENSELY PERSONAL HEALTH CARE DECISIONS ARE BEST MADE BETWEEN PATIENTS AND THEIR DOCTORS. EVERY IOWAN DESERVES THE RIGHT TO DECIDE WHEN OR IF TO BECOME A PARENT AND THE IDEA THAT WE WOULD DICTATE OTHERWISE IS ANTITHETICAL TO THE IDEALS OF PERSONAL LIBERTY AND FREEDOM. IF THEY’RE NOT PREPARED TO HAVE A BABY, THEY SHOULDN’T HAVE SEX. IF THEY’RE THAT CONCERNED ABOUT IT, I WILL STAND FOR EVERYONE’S RIGHT TO PRACTICE ABSTINENCE CASS ABORTION HAS LITTLE, IF ANYTHING, TO DO WITH REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS. IT’S AFTER THE FACT THAT NOW THE GOVERNOR IS EXPECTED TO SIGN THE BILL ON FRIDAY. BUT WE DO KNOW THAT THERE ARE GROUPS SUCH AS PLANNED PARENTHOOD THAT ARE PLANNING TO CHALLENGE THE BILL IN COURT. OUT HERE LIVE AT THE STATEHOUSE, ALYSSA GOMEZ, KCCI EIGHT NEWS, IOWA’S NEWS LEADER. THANK YOU, ALYSSA. PHRASING WITHIN THE BILL SAYS ABORTIONS WOULD BE BANNED ONCE A FETAL HEARTBEAT IS DETECTED. SEVERAL OTHER STATES HAVE PASSED SO-CALLED FETAL HEARTBEAT LAWS, BUT SOME DOCTORS WARN THE TERMINOLOGY DOESN’T EASILY TRANSLATE TO MEDICAL SCIENCE. WHILE THE IOWA BILL DOES NOT INCLUDE A LIMIT ON WEEKS OF PREGNANCY, MEDICAL EXPERTS SAY ULTRASOUNDS CAN GENERALLY DETECT CARDIAC FLUTTER AT ABOUT SIX WEEKS. BUT THEY BUT THEY ALSO ADD AN EMBRYO DOESN’T BECOME A FETUS UNTIL ABOUT EIGHT WEEKS INTO PREGNANCY. AND DOESN’T HAVE A HEART. THE BILL IOWA LAWMAKERS JUST APPROVED SAYS A DOCTOR MUST TEST FOR A FETAL HEARTBEAT BEFORE PERFORMING AN ABORTION. THE WOMAN ALSO NEEDS TO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT TEST NOW, WHILE DOCTORS GENERALLY AGREE THAT CARDIAC RHYTHM CAN BE DETECTED AROUND SIX WEEKS, SOME TELL THE ASSOCIATED PRESS THAT THE HEART DOESN’T ACTUALLY FORM UNTIL ABOUT EIGHT WEEKS, AND MANY DOCTORS DON’T EVEN SCHEDULE A FIRST ULTRASOUND UNTIL WEEKS AFTER THAT. UNITYPOINT IN DES MOINES SAYS PREGNANT WOMEN TYPICALLY HAVE THEIR FIRST PRENATAL VISIT. AN ULTRASOUND FOUND AT TEN WEEKS. WE’VE ALSO CONTACTED MERCYONE AND BROADLAWNS ABOUT WHEN THEIR DOCTORS SCHEDULE THE INITIAL ULTRASOUND BUT HAVE NOT HEARD BACK. A DES MOINES REGISTER MEDIACOM IOWA POLL RELEASED BACK IN MARCH SHOWS A MAJORITY OF IOWANS WERE AGAINST RESTRICTING ABORTION. 21% OF PEOPLE SURVEYED SAID THAT THEY BELIEVE ABORTION SHOULD BE COMPLETELY LEGAL. 40% BELIEVE IT SHOULD BE LEGAL IN MOS
Advertisement
'Fetal heartbeat' bill: How each Iowa lawmaker voted in special session
The list below shows how each member of the Iowa House and Senate voted Tuesday, July 11, on House File 732, known as the "fetal heartbeat" bill, which bans abortion once cardiac activity is detected. The bill passed during the one-day special session, and Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds said she'd sign the bill on Friday. Once signed, the bill will go into effect immediately.Coverage: Iowa Legislature passes abortion restrictions, bill goes to governor's deskLawsuit filed to block enforcement of Iowa's new abortion restrictions Video: Lawsuit filed to block enforcement of Iowa's new abortion restrictions6-week abortion ban: How members of Iowa House votedThe bill passed the Iowa House, 56-34. Every Democrat and two Republicans voted against it, while 10 representatives were absent.District 1: Scholten (D), Not votingDistrict 2: Henderson (R), AyeDistrict 3: Jeneary (R), AyeDistrict 4: Wheeler (R), AyeDistrict 5: Dieken (R), NayDistrict 6: Jones (R), AyeDistrict 7: Sexton (R), AyeDistrict 8: A. Meyer (R), AyeDistrict 9: Stone (R), AyeDistrict 10: Wills (R), AyeDistrict 11: Best (R), AyeDistrict 12: Holt (R), AyeDistrict 13: Carlson (R), Not votingDistrict 14: Bossman (R), AyeDistrict 15: Windschitl (R), AyeDistrict 16: Sieck (R), AyeDistrict 17: Wood (R), AyeDistrict 18: Moore (R), AyeDistrict 19: Siegrist (R), AyeDistrict 20: Turek (D), Not votingDistrict 21: Boden (R), AyeDistrict 22: Gustafson (R), AyeDistrict 23: Sorensen (R), AyeDistrict 24: Fry (R), AyeDistrict 25: Wilz (R), AyeDistrict 26: Harris (R), AyeDistrict 27: Judge (D), NayDistrict 28: Young (R), AyeDistrict 29: B. Meyer (D), NayDistrict 30: Srinivas (D), NayDistrict 31: Madison (D), NayDistrict 32: Konfrst (D), NayDistrict 33: Gaines (D), NayDistrict 34: Abdul-Samad (D), NayDistrict 35: Bagniewski (D), NayDistrict 36: Baeth (D), NayDistrict 37: Kniff McCulla (R), Not votingDistrict 38: Dunwell (R), AyeDistrict 39: Olson (D), NayDistrict 40: Gustoff (R), AyeDistrict 41: Buck (D), NayDistrict 42: Matson (D), NayDistrict 43: Andrews (R), AyeDistrict 44: Forbes (D), NayDistrict 45: Lohse (R), Not votingDistrict 46: Gehlbach (R), AyeDistrict 47: Nordman (R), AyeDistrict 48: P. Thompson (R), AyeDistrict 49: Wessel-Kroeschell (D), NayDistrict 50: Wilburn (D), NayDistrict 51: Deyoe (R), AyeDistrict 52: Cahill (D), NayDistrict 53: Fisher (R), AyeDistrict 54: Meggers (R), AyeDistrict 55: Latham (R), AyeDistrict 56: M. Thompson (R), AyeDistrict 57: Grassley (R), AyeDistrict 58: Thomson (R), AyeDistrict 59: Steckman (D), Not votingDistrict 60: Bloomingdale (R), Not votingDistrict 61: Brown-Powers (D), NayDistrict 62: Amos (D), NayDistrict 63: Bergan (R), Not votingDistrict 64: Osmundson (R), AyeDistrict 65: Lundgren (R), AyeDistrict 66: Bradley (R), AyeDistrict 67: Johnson (R), AyeDistrict 68: Ingels (R), AyeDistrict 69: Determann (R), Not votingDistrict 70: Mommsen (R), AyeDistrict 71: James (D), Not votingDistrict 72: Isenhart (D), NayDistrict 73: Wilson (D), NayDistrict 74: Gjerde (D), NayDistrict 75: Kressig (D), NayDistrict 76: Wulf (R), AyeDistrict 77: Cooling (D), NayDistrict 78: Scheetz (D), NayDistrict 79: Ehlert (D), NayDistrict 80: Staed (D), NayDistrict 81: Stoltenberg (R), AyeDistrict 82: Kaufmann (R), AyeDistrict 83: Golding (R), AyeDistrict 84: Gerhold (R), AyeDistrict 85: Nielsen (D), NayDistrict 86: Jacoby (D), NayDistrict 87: J. Shipley (R), AyeDistrict 88: Hayes (R), AyeDistrict 89: Levin (D), NayDistrict 90: Zabner (D), NayDistrict 91: Sherman (R), AyeDistrict 92: Hora (R), AyeDistrict 93: Mohr (R), AyeDistrict 94: Vondran (R), AyeDistrict 95: Collins (R), AyeDistrict 96: Cisneros (R), NayDistrict 97: Croken (D), NayDistrict 98: Kurth (D), NayDistrict 99: Rinker (R), AyeDistrict 100: Graber (R), Aye6-week abortion ban: How members of Iowa Senate votedThe bill passed the Iowa Senate, 32, 17. All Republicans but one, Sen. Mike Klimesh, R-Spillville, voted in favor, while every Democrat voted against. One was absent. District 1: De Witt (R), AyeDistrict 2: J. Taylor (R), AyeDistrict 3: Evans (R), AyeDistrict 4: Kraayenbrink (R), AyeDistrict 5: Rowley (R), AyeDistrict 6: Schultz (R), AyeDistrict 7: Alons (R), Not votingDistrict 8: Costello (R), AyeDistrict 9: Shipley (R), AyeDistrict 10: Dawson (R), AyeDistrict 11: Garrett (R), AyeDistrict 12: Sinclair (R), AyeDistrict 13: Westrich (R), AyeDistrict 14: Trone Garriott (D), NayDistrict 15: Bisignano (D), NayDistrict 16: Celsi (D), NayDistrict 17: Knox (D), NayDistrict 18: Petersen (D), NayDistrict 19: Rozenboom (R), AyeDistrict 20: Boulton (D), NayDistrict 21: Bousselot (R), AyeDistrict 22: Zaun (R), AyeDistrict 23: Whitver (R), AyeDistrict 24: Green (R), AyeDistrict 25: Quirmbach (D), NayDistrict 26: Edler (R), AyeDistrict 27: Sweeney (R), AyeDistrict 28: Guth (R), AyeDistrict 29: Salmon (R), AyeDistrict 30: Brown (R), AyeDistrict 31: Dotzler (D), NayDistrict 32: Klimesh (R), NayDistrict 33: Koelker (R), AyeDistrict 34: Zumbach (R), AyeDistrict 35: Cournoyer (R), AyeDistrict 36: Jochum (D), NayDistrict 37: Donahue (D), NayDistrict 38: Giddens (D), NayDistrict 39: Bennett (D), NayDistrict 40: T. Taylor (D), NayDistrict 41: Gruenhagen (R), AyeDistrict 42: McClintock (R), AyeDistrict 43: Wahls (D), NayDistrict 44: Dickey (R), AyeDistrict 45: Weiner (D), NayDistrict 46: Driscoll (R), AyeDistrict 47: Webster (R), AyeDistrict 48: Lofgren (R), AyeDistrict 49: Winckler (D), NayDistrict 50: Reichman (R), AyeSource: Iowa Legislative Services Agency

The list below shows how each member of the Iowa House and Senate voted Tuesday, July 11, on House File 732, known as the "fetal heartbeat" bill, which bans abortion once cardiac activity is detected.

The bill passed during the one-day special session, and Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds said she'd sign the bill on Friday. Once signed, the bill will go into effect immediately.

Advertisement

Coverage:

Iowa Legislature passes abortion restrictions, bill goes to governor's desk

Lawsuit filed to block enforcement of Iowa's new abortion restrictions


Video: Lawsuit filed to block enforcement of Iowa's new abortion restrictions

6-week abortion ban: How members of Iowa House voted

The bill passed the Iowa House, 56-34. Every Democrat and two Republicans voted against it, while 10 representatives were absent.

District 1: Scholten (D), Not voting

District 2: Henderson (R), Aye

District 3: Jeneary (R), Aye

District 4: Wheeler (R), Aye

District 5: Dieken (R), Nay

District 6: Jones (R), Aye

District 7: Sexton (R), Aye

District 8: A. Meyer (R), Aye

District 9: Stone (R), Aye

District 10: Wills (R), Aye

District 11: Best (R), Aye

District 12: Holt (R), Aye

District 13: Carlson (R), Not voting

District 14: Bossman (R), Aye

District 15: Windschitl (R), Aye

District 16: Sieck (R), Aye

District 17: Wood (R), Aye

District 18: Moore (R), Aye

District 19: Siegrist (R), Aye

District 20: Turek (D), Not voting

District 21: Boden (R), Aye

District 22: Gustafson (R), Aye

District 23: Sorensen (R), Aye

District 24: Fry (R), Aye

District 25: Wilz (R), Aye

District 26: Harris (R), Aye

District 27: Judge (D), Nay

District 28: Young (R), Aye

District 29: B. Meyer (D), Nay

District 30: Srinivas (D), Nay

District 31: Madison (D), Nay

District 32: Konfrst (D), Nay

District 33: Gaines (D), Nay

District 34: Abdul-Samad (D), Nay

District 35: Bagniewski (D), Nay

District 36: Baeth (D), Nay

District 37: Kniff McCulla (R), Not voting

District 38: Dunwell (R), Aye

District 39: Olson (D), Nay

District 40: Gustoff (R), Aye

District 41: Buck (D), Nay

District 42: Matson (D), Nay

District 43: Andrews (R), Aye

District 44: Forbes (D), Nay

District 45: Lohse (R), Not voting

District 46: Gehlbach (R), Aye

District 47: Nordman (R), Aye

District 48: P. Thompson (R), Aye

District 49: Wessel-Kroeschell (D), Nay

District 50: Wilburn (D), Nay

District 51: Deyoe (R), Aye

District 52: Cahill (D), Nay

District 53: Fisher (R), Aye

District 54: Meggers (R), Aye

District 55: Latham (R), Aye

District 56: M. Thompson (R), Aye

District 57: Grassley (R), Aye

District 58: Thomson (R), Aye

District 59: Steckman (D), Not voting

District 60: Bloomingdale (R), Not voting

District 61: Brown-Powers (D), Nay

District 62: Amos (D), Nay

District 63: Bergan (R), Not voting

District 64: Osmundson (R), Aye

District 65: Lundgren (R), Aye

District 66: Bradley (R), Aye

District 67: Johnson (R), Aye

District 68: Ingels (R), Aye

District 69: Determann (R), Not voting

District 70: Mommsen (R), Aye

District 71: James (D), Not voting

District 72: Isenhart (D), Nay

District 73: Wilson (D), Nay

District 74: Gjerde (D), Nay

District 75: Kressig (D), Nay

District 76: Wulf (R), Aye

District 77: Cooling (D), Nay

District 78: Scheetz (D), Nay

District 79: Ehlert (D), Nay

District 80: Staed (D), Nay

District 81: Stoltenberg (R), Aye

District 82: Kaufmann (R), Aye

District 83: Golding (R), Aye

District 84: Gerhold (R), Aye

District 85: Nielsen (D), Nay

District 86: Jacoby (D), Nay

District 87: J. Shipley (R), Aye

District 88: Hayes (R), Aye

District 89: Levin (D), Nay

District 90: Zabner (D), Nay

District 91: Sherman (R), Aye

District 92: Hora (R), Aye

District 93: Mohr (R), Aye

District 94: Vondran (R), Aye

District 95: Collins (R), Aye

District 96: Cisneros (R), Nay

District 97: Croken (D), Nay

District 98: Kurth (D), Nay

District 99: Rinker (R), Aye

District 100: Graber (R), Aye

6-week abortion ban: How members of Iowa Senate voted

The bill passed the Iowa Senate, 32, 17. All Republicans but one, Sen. Mike Klimesh, R-Spillville, voted in favor, while every Democrat voted against. One was absent.

District 1: De Witt (R), Aye

District 2: J. Taylor (R), Aye

District 3: Evans (R), Aye

District 4: Kraayenbrink (R), Aye

District 5: Rowley (R), Aye

District 6: Schultz (R), Aye

District 7: Alons (R), Not voting

District 8: Costello (R), Aye

District 9: Shipley (R), Aye

District 10: Dawson (R), Aye

District 11: Garrett (R), Aye

District 12: Sinclair (R), Aye

District 13: Westrich (R), Aye

District 14: Trone Garriott (D), Nay

District 15: Bisignano (D), Nay

District 16: Celsi (D), Nay

District 17: Knox (D), Nay

District 18: Petersen (D), Nay

District 19: Rozenboom (R), Aye

District 20: Boulton (D), Nay

District 21: Bousselot (R), Aye

District 22: Zaun (R), Aye

District 23: Whitver (R), Aye

District 24: Green (R), Aye

District 25: Quirmbach (D), Nay

District 26: Edler (R), Aye

District 27: Sweeney (R), Aye

District 28: Guth (R), Aye

District 29: Salmon (R), Aye

District 30: Brown (R), Aye

District 31: Dotzler (D), Nay

District 32: Klimesh (R), Nay

District 33: Koelker (R), Aye

District 34: Zumbach (R), Aye

District 35: Cournoyer (R), Aye

District 36: Jochum (D), Nay

District 37: Donahue (D), Nay

District 38: Giddens (D), Nay

District 39: Bennett (D), Nay

District 40: T. Taylor (D), Nay

District 41: Gruenhagen (R), Aye

District 42: McClintock (R), Aye

District 43: Wahls (D), Nay

District 44: Dickey (R), Aye

District 45: Weiner (D), Nay

District 46: Driscoll (R), Aye

District 47: Webster (R), Aye

District 48: Lofgren (R), Aye

District 49: Winckler (D), Nay

District 50: Reichman (R), Aye

Source: Iowa Legislative Services Agency